Miss Monticello & Miss Monticello's Outstanding Teen Pageant

Pageant History

Home
Pageant History
Areas of Competition
Application Information

mcello.jpg
Aleigh Oney, Ann-Blair Thornton & Elizabeth Ellis

a4y7396newspaperimage.jpg
Kaitlynne Postel, Miss Kentucky 2007, with her Miss Monticello director, Joey Neal.

 

The Miss Monticello Pageant was held for the first time in 1996.  Since that time the pageant has grown each year by leaps and bounds.  The first Miss Teen Monticello was chosen in 1998.  In 2003 the first Little Miss Monticello Pageant was conducted with winners selected in five age categories.  2005 marked the first ever Miss Wayne County Area.  In 2008 a second teen title was added for that year.  In this section you will find a listing of the winners each year, plus the awards they received at their respective state pageants.

MISS MONTICELLO

2017: Susanna White

            Preliminary Talent Award

               Top 11 Finalist


2016: Dakoda Trenary

           Top 11 Finalist


2015: Madison McCowan

           Top 13 Finalist

 

2014: Kiley Brennan Shuffett

          Top 13 Finalist

 

2013: Miranda Buchanan

 

2012: Annie Franklin

          Preliminary Swimsuit Winner

            3rd runner-up

 

2011: Shaina Esser

            Top 13 Finalist

 

2010: Ann-Blair Thornton

           1st runner-up

           National Sweetheart 1st runner-up

             Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National Sweetheart

 

2009: Kelly Casey

           Top 10 Finalist

 

2008: Hannah Herald

 

2007: Kaitlynne Postel

           Miss Kentucky 2007

 

2006: Anne Claire Correll

           Preliminary Talent Winner

              Top 10 Finalist

 

2005: Sarah Billiter

              Top 10 Finalist

 

2004: Lindsay Block

           Top 10 Finalist


2003: MacKenzie Mayes

         Preliminary Swimsuit Winner

           Community Service Winner

           Quality of Life Winner

           Miss Kentucky 2003

           Miss America Nonfinalist Talent Winner

           1st runner-up Miss America Quality of Life Award

      

2002: Bethany Moore

           Preliminary Swimsuit Winner

           3rd Runner-Up to Miss Kentucky

 

2001: Kari Lee Rustay

 

2000: MacKenzie Mayes

         Community Service Winner

           1st Runner-up to Miss Kentucky

           National Sweetheart Winner

           Preliminary Swimsuit Winner at National Sweetheart

           Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National Sweetheart

           

1999: Tonya Ramsey

           Non-finalist Interview Winner

 

1998: Beth Sweeney

           Top 10 Miss Kentucky

 

1997: Robin Litteral

           Community Service Winner

           Top 10 Miss Kentucky

 

1996: Chera-Lyn Cook

         Preliminary Talent Winner

           Top 10 Miss Kentucky

 

MISS TEEN MONTICELLO

2017: Turner Reynolds

             Preliminary Evening Wear Winner

                Top 11 Finalist


2016: Reagan Earlywine


2015: Chapel Tinius

          Preliminary Talent Award

            Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award

            Overall Talent Winner

            4th Runner Up at MKOT

          

'2014: Makayela Banks

 

2013: Laura Hancock

           Preliminary Talent Award

             Preliminary Fitness Award

             Miss Kentucky's Outstanding Teen 2013

 

2012: Abigail Stanley

 

2011: Kathryn Robinson

            Top 12 finalist

 

2010: Aleigh Oney

          1st runner-up

           Community Service Award

 

2009: Emily Eicher

            Nonfinalist Talent Award

 

2008: Katie Himes

 

2007: Kayla Allen

 

2006: Emily Eicher

 

2005: Leslie Dobbs

 

2004: Katisha Pickrell

           Top 10 Finalist


2003: Natalie Denney

 

2002: India Hammond

 

2001: Natalie Brown

           1st runner-up to Miss Teen Kentucky

 

2000: Rebecca Dishman

 

1999: Jennifer Lewis

 

1998: Bethany Moore

 

MISS TEEN WAYNE COUNTY AREA

2017: Ally Alred

            Top 11 Finalist


2016: NO TITLE AWARDED


2015: Callie Halsey

 

2014: Molly Dalton

             Non-Finalist Talent Award

                Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award

                Community Service Award

           

2013: Talia Horn

             Top 12 Finalist

 

2012: Molly Dalton

 

2011: Talia Horn

            Top 12 Finalist

 

2010: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2009: Madison Gooch

            Top 10 Finalist

 

2008: Yasmin Blevins

 

MISS WAYNE COUNTY AREA

2017: Charlee Schaefer

            Preliminary Talent Award

              Non-Finalist Talent Award


2016: Molly Matney

           Top 11 Finalist

 

2015: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2014: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2013: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2012: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2011: Jefra Bland

            2nd Runner-up

 

2010: Elizabeth Ellis

 

2009: NO TITLE AWARDED

 

2008: Elizabeth Hood

           Preliminary Swimsuit Winner

 

2007: Katisha Pickrell

 

2006: Ean Whitney Cox

 

2005: Rebecca Dishman

 

LITTLE MISS MONTICELLO

 

2008: Wee Little Miss Monticello, Sara Grace Muse
           Petite Little Miss Monticello, Chapel Tinius
                                    (Talent Award winner at Mini Miss Kentucky)
           Junior Miss Monticello, Shelby England
                                    (1st runner-up to Petite Miss Kentucky)
            Pre-Teen Miss Monticello, Ansley Stalcup
2007: Wee Little Miss Monticello, Nicole Abbott, Monticello
         Tiny Little Miss Monticello, Qua'Neisha Prater, Monticello
         Petite Little Miss Monticello, Jessica Hill, Rockholds
                                      (1st runner-up to Petite Miss Kentucky)
         Junior Little Miss Monticello, Katie Dice, Germantown
         Pre-Teen Little Miss Monticello, Harley Rose, Monticello
 

2006: Wee Little Miss Monticello, Kari Cook, Radcliff

           Tiny Little Miss Monticello, Haleigh Criswell, Monticello

           Petite Little Miss Monticello, Shayla Price, Radcliff

                (Overall Most Photogenic at Little Miss Kentucky)

           Junior Little Miss Monticello, Skylar Durham, Richmond

           Pre-Teen Little Miss Monticello, Kennedy McAlpin, Somerset

 

2005: Wee Little Miss Monticello, Haleigh Criswell, Monticello 

                        (Talent Winner, 1st runner-up to Wee Miss Kentucky)

           Tiny Little Miss Monticello, Emma Landherr, Louisville

                                                (Tiny Miss Kentucky)

           Petite Little Miss Monticello, Ansley Stalcup, Albany 

                                    (Talent Winner, Petite Miss Kentucky)

           Junior Little Miss Monticello, Kennedy McAlpin, Somerset

           Pre-Teen Miss Monticello, Taylor Howell, Somerset

 

2004: Wee Little Miss Monticello - Haleigh Criswell, Monticello

           Tiny Little Miss Monticello - Brenna Jones, Richmond

                                                           (Tiny Little Miss Kentucky)

           Little Miss Monticello - Haleigh Guffey, Albany

           Junior Little Miss Monticello - Kennedy McAlpin, Somerset

                                                              (Junior Little Miss Kentucky)

           Pre-teen Little Miss Monticello - Kelli Hensley, Berea

2003: Wee Little Miss Monticello - Kaitlyn Creech, Jamestown

           Tiny Little Miss Monticello - Alyssa Delph, Lily

           Petite Little Miss Monticello - Sasha Hutton, Monticello

           Junior Little Miss Monticello - Harley Rose, Monticello

                                                 (2nd runner-up to Junior Little Miss KY)

           Pre-teen Little Miss Monticello - Shelby Parmley, Monticello